How to write a peer review paper

How to write a peer review paper

10/8/ · Be upfront and honest with the authors and the editor about which scientific aspects you will focus on in your review. After the first reading, attempt to ‘mirror’ the article by writing down, in Follow the golden rule: Write the type of review you’d want to receive if you were the author. Even if you decide not to identify yourself in the review, you should write comments that you would be comfortable signing your name to. In your comments, use phrases like “ the authors’ discussion of X” instead of “ your discussion of X.” How to peer review. Peer review is designed to assess the validity, quality and originality of articles for publication. Reviewers play an essential role in validating the research submitted and providing constructive feedback to the editors and authors. You can find more detail about the peer review

How to Write a Peer Review - PLOS

Learning how how to write a peer review paper peer review is no small feat. This on-demand, practical course and comes with one-to-one support with your own mentor.

Journal peer review is a critical tool for ensuring the quality and integrity of the research literature. It is the process by which researchers use their expert knowledge of a topic to assess an article for its accuracy and rigor, and to help make sure it builds on and adds to the current literature. It teaches you how to review a manuscriptspot common flaws in research papersand improve your own chances of being a successful published author.

To get the most out of the peer review process, you'll want to keep some best practice tips and techniques in mind from the start.

This will help you write a review around two to three pages four maximum in length. We asked an expert panel of researchers what steps they take to ensure a thorough and robust review. We then compiled their advice into 12 easy steps with link to blog posts for further information:.

Check out our post, Are you the right reviewer? for our checklist to assess whether you should take on a certain peer review request. Check the manuscript fits in the journal format and the references are standardised if the editor has not already done so. Underline key words and arguments, and summarise key points. Make sure you have the tables, figures and references visible.

Ask yourself key questions, including: Does it have a relevant title and valuable research question? Are key papers referenced?

Are the data and tools suitable and correct? Why does that matter? Are there other considerations? Find out how to write a peer review paper in our step guide to critically reviewing a manuscript. You need to make sure you can put the paper down and come back to it with fresh eyes how to write a peer review paper on. Note-taking is essential for this. Check out our guide for common research flaws to watch out for, how to write a peer review paper.

For example, how to write a peer review paper, does the referenced study actually show what is claimed in the paper? Does the paper flow? Does it have connectivity? Does it have clarity? Are the words and structure concise and effective? Check previous publications of the authors and of other authors in the field to be sure that the results were not published before. Try to compile this in a logical way, grouping similar things under a common heading where possible, and numbering them for ease of reference.

What do you want them to work on? in the manuscript that the authors can do. We hope these 12 steps help get you on your way for your first peer review, or improving the structure of your current reviews.

Sign up today. Our expert panel of reviewers include: Ana Marie Florea Heinrich-Heine-Universität DüsseldorfJames Cotter University of Otagoand Robert Faff University of Queensland.

These reviewers are all recipients of the Global Peer Review Awards powered by Publons. They also and boast hundreds of pre-publication peer reviews for more than different journals and sit on numerous editorial boards. Menu Close Home Subscribe. The peer review process Journal peer review is a critical tool for ensuring the quality and integrity of the research literature. We then compiled their advice into 12 easy steps with link to blog posts for further information: 1 Make sure you have the right expertise.

Sign up today Our expert panel of reviewers include: Ana Marie Florea Heinrich-Heine-Universität DüsseldorfJames Cotter University of Otagoand Robert Faff University of Queensland. GIF via GIPHY Publons allows you to record, verify, and showcase your peer review contributions in a format you can include in job and funding applications without breaking reviewer anonymity.

Register now to start building your verified peer review record.

Peer Review Example

, time: 2:08

How to write a thorough peer review

6/20/ · Review your own report. Set aside your peer review report and let it sit for a day or two. You will have fresh eyes when you come back to it. Make sure to do the following before submitting: How to peer review. Peer review is designed to assess the validity, quality and originality of articles for publication. Reviewers play an essential role in validating the research submitted and providing constructive feedback to the editors and authors. You can find more detail about the peer review Follow the golden rule: Write the type of review you’d want to receive if you were the author. Even if you decide not to identify yourself in the review, you should write comments that you would be comfortable signing your name to. In your comments, use phrases like “ the authors’ discussion of X” instead of “ your discussion of X.”